Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Heather's avatar

"Can I suggest the fine should be even more when the instrument is a recorder?"

Well, that's debatable. I mean, consider the offensive noise Albanese, Wong and Thorpe emit every time they open their mouth? After having to suffer that, any noise from a screeching recorder player would be heavenly music in comparison.

Expand full comment
Heather's avatar

"Playing a musical instrument and “emitting offensive noise” could cost you a $300 fine in NSW."

Oh dear. Given that all three of my children are learning musical instruments and both my husband and I teach instrumental music as a living and operate this business partly from home, I guess we are doing some very risky business.

Furthermore, given that we encourage our students to do lots of practice, what if our students sue us because they got fined for making 'offensive noise' as a result of their neighbour dobbing on them?

Well, I guess I'll just have to prepare for what I'll say when I get a knock on the door by a police officer. When he tells me I am guilty of 'emitting offensive noise',...

I could say "To call Beethoven's music 'offensive noise' is racist against Germans! And as someone who has German heritage, I am offended by your racist comments."

Or I could say "Tell the bitter and twisted neighbour to take up an instrument. It'll help them feel less offended!!"

Or I could say "Thank you!! Given that the premiere of Stravinsky's famous 'The Rite of Spring' was so offensive to the audience that the audience actually began throwing their chairs at the orchestra, I'll take that as a compliment!"

Expand full comment
34 more comments...

No posts